The Science is Impossible

209 notes

Explaining Decompression in Comics

bigbigtruck:

heysawbones:

bigbigtruck:

rosalarian:

Man, I didn’t even know stuff like this was a “controversy” in comics. Very interesting.


This is a really good post.

The “Western vs. Japanese” bent of the article bothers me a little, because “decompression” is something often found in Western independent work, and I somehow suspect it’s not something every single one of those creators derived from manga. Decompression is a style of panelling and writing that comes naturally to people who prioritize particular certain aspects of narrative over (or at least as much as) the plot elements described as endemic to “Western superhero comics” by the article.


hah, I’ve gotten so used to the West vs. East slant in comics journalism that I just looked right over it, there. You’re right, though.

While the East versus West slant is somewhat legitimate, it’s not universally applicable.  What I find interesting about this ‘decompression’ argument, is that it is essentially an argument of TIMING and PACING.  What makes me sad is how much of the argument on the super-hero comics side is based on sales, not the quality of the comic.  They are more concerned with making sure the reader gets their money’s worth each month, rather than how the pacing will inevitably affect the quality and clarity of the comic in the long run.  Not that fast-facing is inherently bad….if anything I find that on average, pacing is at it’s best when it’s varied.  A constant high-pace is tiresome to read, and a constant slow pace can also grow boring.  Every comic and story has it’s own balance depending on the needs and style of the creator to tell that story, but one approach isn’t inherently better than any other.

  1. professorcolorblind reblogged this from pennsylvania6-5000
  2. peppermint-dicks reblogged this from rosalarian
  3. badrowboatcop reblogged this from kaeferlein
  4. remuslupinly reblogged this from mi-na-to-rise-up
  5. novazembla reblogged this from rosalarian
  6. schompie reblogged this from doublecross-comic
  7. iandsharman reblogged this from srgrgerg and added:
    "The average American comic book features acres of text, and incredibly dense story telling." Wuh…? "I rarely touch...
  8. srgrgerg reblogged this from themarionettequintet
  9. bloodmagicanddawndetergent reblogged this from bigbigtruck and added:
    It’s all about balance. I don’t like reading American comics because they seem heavy and cluttered to me, but it is...
  10. sufliso reblogged this from nofna
  11. captainsamcarter reblogged this from bigbigtruck
  12. ogiuemaniax reblogged this from rosalarian and added:
    Reblogging my own blog post to create a feedback loop.
  13. razmataaz reblogged this from bigbigtruck and added:
    Really interesting stuff! I ignore the east v. west set up though. That slant is mostly just generalizations, but...
  14. geewhathappensnext reblogged this from rosalarian and added:
    Hmm, i think they mean meandering or poor pacing more than compressed or not. Part of the reason I dropped manga was the...
  15. angfdz reblogged this from rosalarian
  16. wispus reblogged this from nofna and added:
    leans out of the way of conversation
  17. nofna reblogged this from escapefromsuicidewolf and added:
    I’ve always thought of it as storyboarding for animation. The reader has a “frames per second” count and I need to...
  18. nonvieta reblogged this from bigbigtruck and added:
    While the East versus West slant is somewhat legitimate, it’s not universally applicable. What I find interesting about...
  19. fangshinobi reblogged this from bigbigtruck and added:
    How about ten chapters in a manga dedicated to battles? Twenty chapters? Thirty chapters? I don’t even make sense.
  20. floipenstein reblogged this from escapefromsuicidewolf
  21. escapefromsuicidewolf reblogged this from buttastic